Elimination of Long-Form Census Questionnaire seen as Short Sighted
The Harper government’s decision to eliminate the long-form census questionnaire to be replaced by a voluntary survey that will ultimately cost more than the current system is seen as short sighted by Queer Ontario. For years, queers have been lobbying and working with Statistics Canada to include the gender and sexually diverse in their census and surveys.
Not only will this decision (taken without consultation) abrogate the collection of important data that serves the development and growth of Canada in its business, charitable/nonprofit and public sectors, but seriously disrupt the continuation of ongoing data analysis in longitudinal studies Statistics Canada undertakes.
Research experts across the country have already deemed the Tories’ proposed voluntary survey as statistically unreliable. Claims by the federal government that the mandatory imposition of the long-form census questionnaire intrudes on Canadians’ privacy and that they were advised to pursue their new proposal by Statistics Canada have been discredited by the high standards of confidentiality that StatsCan operates by and by the recent resignation of StatsCan’s head.
“What really lies behind such a short-sighted decision is less about protecting the privacy of Canadians, but more so about an ideologically driven agenda that would severely curtail evidence-based research substantiating the arguments of initiatives and populations the Tories are not interested in supporting,” says Nick Mulé, founder of Queer Ontario. He added, “Should they succeed at eliminating the long-form census questionnaire, they will have set the stage for a diminished Statistics Canada in which groups will no longer be able to rely on for evidence, thus weakening the latter’s advocacy and lobbying efforts.”
At stake for queers across the province and country:
- Ongoing efforts to get sexual orientation and gender identity included in the Canada census and various Statistics Canada surveys
- The ability to gather reliable data on queer identity, behaviour and issues from a voluntary sample
- Strategies and discussions with Statistics Canada regarding how to include queers, if at all, in the new instrument
- The opportunity to continue discussions with and education of Statistics Canada personnel regarding queer social issues, beyond legal issues in the face of this potential upheaval
- The hope of one day having evidence-based data to advocate for policies, funding, programs and services that recognize and meet the needs of queers
Therefore, Queer Ontario calls on the federal government to not pursue a voluntary survey and to retain the long-form census questionnaire.
You missed the opportunity to highlight that the only options on the Census for trans people to identify are male and female.
The introduction of a so-called “short” census questionnaire, apart from it’s intent to be exclusionary and ideologically driven,is a manipulative ploy to win the non-questioning part of the citizenry to anything that seems less bureaucratically demanding.
The response from QO is clear, timely, explanatory, and responsive to the needs of queers.
May be “responsive to needs of queers”, however lacks insight into trans people’s lives, particularly because the Census sex categories are Male OR Female only.
If not to highlight this when census is matter of public conversation, then when to advocate for trans people?
Indeed it is important that trans people be acknowledged and recognized by StatsCan, particularly given the complete absence of these populations in the census and surveys.
As such, both gender and sexually diverse populations are captured in the Queer Ontario statement on the census as we see and value the importance of the full queer communities being represented.
NOTE: Susan Gapka is a member of Queer Ontario.
Thanks Nick for posting.
As a new organisation and with the G20 & Pride Toronto interventions it has been challenging to sort out some of the different needs of our communities and our members. I appreciate Queer Ontario’s support on the Ontario and Canadian Trans Human Rights Campaigns.
Respectfully;
Susan Gapka
Justin, how do I import a profile picture?
If you have a WordPress.com account already go here: http://en.gravatar.com